| Year | Team | Head Coach |
| 2024 | | |
| 2023 | | |
| 2022 | | |
| 2020 | Sir Charles Tupper Tigers | Mike Morgan |
| 2019 | Dr Knox Falcons | Matthew Heyworth |
| 2018 | Sir Charles Tupper Tigers | Jordan McAlpine |
| 2017 | Lake Trail Lakers | Craig Follis & Lance Lloyd |
| 2016 | Sir Charles Tupper Tigers | Ron Roquillo |
| 2015 | – not awarded – | – not awarded – |
| 2014 | Dr Knox Falcons | Fred Bourcier |
| 2013 | Dr Knox Falcons | David Lafontaine |
| 2012 | – not awarded – | – not awarded – |
| 2011 | Dr Knox Falcons | Dave Ludba |
| 2010 | KLO Cougars | Mark Steen & Garth Dupré |
| 2009 | Constable Neil Bruce Cubs | Gerry Kroeker |
| 2008 | Dr Knox Falcons | Dave Ludba |
| 2007 | St Michael’s University Blue Jags | Reagan Daly |
| 2006 | Trafalgar Totems | Lorne Wuori |
| 2005 | Handsworth Royals | Blair Shier |
| 2004 | St George’s Saints | |
| 2003 | Trafalgar Totems | Lorne Wuori |
| 2002 | MEI Eagles | Jim Williams |
| 2001 | St George’s Saints | Ed Taylor |
| 2000 | St George’s Saints | Ed Taylor |
| 1999 | Trafalgar Totems | Lorne Wuori |
| 1998 | Vancouver College Fighting Irish | Brian Lee |
